“Nothing is permanent in this wicked world, not even our
troubles.” – Charles Chaplin
The company’s attorney worked
behind the scenes and his office contacted all the Attorneys General to
arrange a conference call to discuss the situation. Although many Attorneys
General hadn’t received any complaints about NCEB, he wanted to be proactive
and get everyone together on the phone. He felt it was faster and less
costly to clear things up with the entire group, rather than having to deal
separately with different parties.
Naturally, it benefited Johnny and
his partners to have an agreement in place that said they had no legal
problems, so they were extremely supportive of the idea. The company’s
attorney accumulated detailed information about the operations as proof the
company offered real products and services. He had documentation supporting
all of the discounts with national merchants, the VISA banking agreement,
the arrangements with book wholesalers, and letters from the various
suppliers detailing the steps taken to create the business.
Since College Card already offered
full refunds to anyone that felt confused by the marketing, there were
arguably no injured parties. The attorney’s job was to be the voice
of reason and remind the group that they were dealing with three 22 year-old
entrepreneurs. He argued that although errors of judgment were made, the
partners had good intentions and had already taken steps to rectify their
mistakes. He demonstrated that the whole situation was a giant
misunderstanding.
Within weeks, Johnny and his
partners signed an agreement with a division of the Federal Post Office.
They were never charged with any wrong doing. They just walked into their
attorney’s office and signed a “voluntary agreement of compliance.” It laid
out the allegations, stated that Johnny and his partners denied any wrong
doing and that they agreed never to do anything that resembled those
allegations in the future. They also agreed to close the NCEB business,
which had been the focal point of the controversy. The NCEB mail was
returned to sender by the post office, so Johnny and his partners never got
to know how many responses they received from their direct mail campaign.